Cohiba Siglo I vs Trinidad Reyes – Which is The Best Short Cigar?

In the world of Cuban cigars, few names carry as much weight as Cohiba and Trinidad. Both brands sit firmly at the top of the pyramid when it comes to prestige, history and craftsmanship. In our latest video, we decided to take a closer look at two of their most compact offerings: the Cohiba Siglo I and the Trinidad Reyes.

These are cigars that were once staples in the daily rotation of many cigar lovers. Compact in size but often rich in character, they offered a convenient way to enjoy Cuban flavour without the time commitment of a larger format. The Siglo I comes in at four inches with a ring gauge of 40, while the Reyes is slightly longer at four and three eighths, also with a ring gauge of 40. They are similar enough to make for a fair comparison, but different enough to spark debate.

In this video, we take a close look at each cigar from the moment they are cut and lit. We explore flavour development, strength, construction and draw. How do these cigars hold up today? What has changed since their heyday? And how do they compare in terms of value, especially considering the recent price increases that have hit both brands?

Throughout the video, I smoke both cigars all the way through, sharing impressions at every stage. This is not just about flavour notes. It is about performance. It is about consistency. It is about how well each cigar delivers the kind of experience we now expect from top tier Cuban brands.

Whether you are new to Cuban cigars or a seasoned smoker looking to revisit old favourites, this video offers a detailed, unfiltered comparison of two legendary smokes. Click the video to find out which one comes out on top.